Strathcona, Vancouver

558 Keefer Street

In the city directories 1912–1955.

Three named households between 1913 and 1935: John McPhee, Harry Trollope and Mrs M Flynn. The 1930 name section gives James Dennis, a driver, at this address (page 181), matched to the 1930 listing here by first name or initials (inferred). It is also listed as Vacant store (1912), Keefer Rooms (1920), Keefer Lodge (1925–1930) and Keefer Lodge (1940–1945).

Open this house's bookIts history laid out as a book, chapter by chapter, each line with its page, to read here or save as a PDF to print or give.

The building at 558 Keefer Street, three storeys with stacked bay windows over a ground floor with two doors, cars at the curb
March 1974 The building at 558 Keefer Street, three storeys with stacked bay windows over a ground floor with two doors, cars at the curb. Taken after the years the directories here cover; the house may have changed since. City of Vancouver Archives, CVA 1095-02509. Copyright City of Vancouver.

Who lived here

Read in 17 directories. Each chapter is one surname at this address across the directories, so it can be more than one family; tap a name for its directory page, or follow the name to every address it's printed at. After 1945 the directories' names aren't shown.

  1. Not in the directory
    1905–1911
  2. I1912
  3. II1913
  4. III1915
  5. IV1920
  6. V
    Keefer Lodge9 to 10 listings a year
    1925–1930
  7. VI1935
  8. VII
    Keefer Lodgerooms to let
    1940–1945
  9. VIII
    4 listings4 listings
    1955

The book adds to the chapters with this mark: everyone the directory lists at this address that year, with their work, and the page behind every line. See what it holds, or quote this house.

1910
permit to build brick stores
13
names listed in its suites, 1925–1930, besides 3 households named 1913–1935
Rebuilt in 1963
today, by the City's records

The building

A permit to build brick stores was taken out in November 1910 by T W Hemphill, owner and builder: $5,000. Most of its directory years list it as a building rather than a household. In 1912 it is listed as Vacant store. By 1913 a household is listed here, John McPhee, one of two listings there. In 1915, after the McPhee household, the number has Harry Trollope, one of two listings there. After the Trollope household, in 1920 it is listed as Keefer Rooms.

From 1925 to 1930 it is a building of suites or rooms, Keefer Lodge, with 9 to 10 listings a year. By 1935 a household is listed here, Mrs M Flynn, one of two listings there. After the Flynn household, from 1940 to 1945 it is listed as Keefer Lodge. In 1955 it is a building of suites or rooms, with 4 listings.

Where the directory printed “Japanese”, its canvassers wrote a group label in place of the residents' names; we show what was printed, and the names it never recorded we can't give.

Also at this address in 1930, the name section lists Herbert O'Brien, a grader at the City of Vancouver (page 19). The line shares the household's surname, O'Brien, but no first name or initial ties it to the listing here before or after: we can't tell if it is the same family, so we keep it apart.

Since 1955

  1. 1963Today's building goes up, by the City's record.
  2. 1968The south side of the 500 block of Keefer Street is inside the boundary of the City's Urban Renewal Scheme 3 (Strathcona I). The boundary alone doesn't say which blocks were to be cleared. (LEG37.28, dated Aug. 1968)

From City of Vancouver open data (Open Government Licence – Vancouver): the property tax report (BC Assessment's years, approximate for old buildings), business licences from 1997 (the kind of business only), issued building permits from 2017 and the heritage register. The urban-renewal plans: City of Vancouver Archives, each record linked on its line; the plans and maps are under the City's copyright, so we tell what they show and don't reproduce them.

Today

A newer building, dated 1963 by the City, has the address now: the building in these directories is gone, replaced after the 1955 directory, the last we read. Two doors along, 546 still has one from before 1946, one of nine on the block.

To go further on when it was built and by whom: search the City's permit registers for 558 in Heritage Vancouver's transcription, 1901–1930, and ask the City of Vancouver Archives for its water service records, since a house usually applied for water as it was finished. Our guide has the steps.

The lot at 558 Keefer Street on the 1912 fire insurance map
558 Keefer Street on Goad's 1912 map. At 558, the 1912 map draws a brick rooming house labelled Keefer Rooms at the street end of the lot, with two small wood-frame buildings behind it. The map prints no number on this lot (lot 12); it is placed by today's address, which runs in step with the numbered lots beside it (inferred). Goad's Fire Insurance Map, 1912, georectified by the City of Vancouver (Open Government Licence – Vancouver). The circle marks the address.
Keefer StFalse CreekBurrard InletSTRATHCONADOWNTOWNMain StClark DrTerminal AvePowell StClose
558 Keefer Street today: the red dot, on the 500 block of Keefer Street in Strathcona. Beside this: the whole city, with the map above boxed in red. Today's streets, shoreline, parks and local areas: City of Vancouver Open Data (Open Government Licence – Vancouver).

The 1921 and 1931 censuses

1921

On June 1, 1921, the census found nine households here, 22 people in all (eight of the nine households inferred: the census marks the street with a ditto, so we took it from the line above). Of them, eight rented, most at $7.50 a month. Most had one or two rooms. The census lists it as an apartment house.

Origin, as the census gave it: 22 Japanese. Where they were born: 16 in Japan and six in British Columbia.

The 18 people the census names here
The Tavakes, three people, renting
One lodger
The Baginskis, three people, renting
The Wakanoras, three people, renting
The Kitamuras, two people, renting
The Kates, two people, renting
The Skerns, three people, renting
The Ischalkies, one person, renting

One of the households here isn't named. We name a household only where Library and Archives Canada's index of the page agrees with our reading of it on every line: the same number of people, each related to the head the same way.

Origins are the census's own words, some no longer used. Names and relationships are as Library and Archives Canada's index of the census gives them; each links to its record there. Library and Archives Canada, Census of Canada, 1921 (RG31, Statistics Canada fonds), Vancouver Centre (district 22), sub-district 63, pages 29 and 30.

1931

On June 1, 1931, the census found one household here: 20 people, renting at $40 a month, in nine rooms (inferred: the census writes the street once and the numbers under it, so we matched this number to that street). The census lists it as a single house, built of wood.

Origin, as the census gave it: nine English, four Norwegian, two Swedish, one French, one Irish, one Italian, one Spanish and one not given or not readable. Where they were born: nine in British Columbia, two in England, two in Norway, two in Sweden, one in France, one in Ireland, one in Italy, one in New Zealand and one elsewhere.

The census names everyone in each household. We name a person only with their record at Library and Archives Canada, and we don't hold those records for 1931, so we give the counts. Library and Archives Canada, Census of Canada, 1931 (RG31, Statistics Canada fonds), Vancouver Centre (electoral district 236), sub-district 38 (record 85907530), page 25, line 7.

The neighbours

The 500 block of Keefer Street, door by door, the way the directory prints it. This house is marked in red; pick a year to read who lived at every door.

Keefer Street, the 500 blockas the 1935 directory lists it, door by door, and what stands there today

*: some member of the family owns the property, to the best of the directory's knowledge (its own mark, printed from 1935)

South side, even numbers

  1. 510Tennant AndwYeoman JExcelsior Apts rooms*Excelsior Apt +1Excelsior Rooms & AptsExcelsior Roomsgone
  2. 514Chinese MissionGoldberg —vacantvacantGoldberg J (whse)Lions Gate Moving & Stge +1stands
  3. 518Kellberg EricMandleman J*Mandleman J*Babaval J*Babaval J*a household · rooms to letstands
  4. 520not listednot listednot listednot listednot listednot listedgone
  5. 522Rudd Hans“Chinese”Johnson ELundvall ELundvall Ea householdstands
  6. 524Bradley Edw“Chinese”Fong WWing Fong +3Chow Ha household · pedlar +2stands
  7. 526Wallings Morley Avacant“Orientals”not listednot listednot listedstands
  8. 532“Chinese”“Chinese”Glowsky SGlowsky SLum Fon*a householdstands
  9. 534not listednot listednot listednot listednot listednot listedgone
  10. 536Mohrman Oscar“Chinese”“Orientals”“Orientals”Jang Kee Shew*a householdrebuilt
  11. 540not listednot listednot listednot listednot listednot listedgone
  12. 542Cima PietroCima P*Cima P*Zagar M“Orientals”*a householdstands
  13. 546“Chinese”“Orientals”“Orientals”“Orientals”*a householdstands
  14. 548“Chinese”“Orientals” +1Sam H +1Sam H +1*a householdrebuilt
  15. 558Keefer Rooms +1Keefer Lodge +8Keefer Lodge rooms +1Keefer LodgeKeefer Lodge roomsa household +3rebuilt
  16. 560Ganter Cvacantnot listednot listednot listedgone
  17. 564a household +1rebuilt
  18. 568Lawrence Jennie“Chinese”“Orientals”Hong JSun Lok Moya householdrebuilt
Who stayed on the 500 block: of the addresses with a named household in both directories, how many still had the same surname in the next directory we've read. A filled house kept its family.

The record

Each directory's listing for this address, as printed, with its page at the Vancouver Public Library. *: some member of the family owns the property, to the best of the directory's knowledge (its own mark, printed from 1935).

1905

Not in the directory this year.

Henderson's City of Vancouver Directory

1906

Not in the directory this year.

Henderson's City of Vancouver Directory

1907

Not in the directory this year.

Henderson's City of Vancouver Directory

1908

Not in the directory this year.

Henderson's City of Vancouver Directory

1909

Not in the directory this year.

Henderson's City of Vancouver Directory

1912
  • Vacant storebusiness
  • Keefer Rooms

Henderson's Greater Vancouver Directory Part 1, p. 88

1913

No job on this line: the 1913 directory prints work in its name section, under McPhee. Open the 1913 directory

Henderson's Greater Vancouver City Directory Part 1, p. 110

1915

No job on this line: the 1915 directory prints work in its name section, under Trollope (near p. 565).

Henderson's Greater Vancouver City Directory, p. 99

1920
  • Keefer Rooms
  • Vacant storebusiness

Henderson's Vancouver Directory, p. 87

1925

The directory printed “Japanese” here instead of names.

No job on this line: the 1925 directory prints work in its name section, under Brown (near p. 114), Williams (near p. 251), Scriber (near p. 156), Otto (near p. 93), Harrison (near p. 299) and Hjorthoy (near p. 315).

The dash (—) is printed in the directory where a first name would go: it gives none.

Reader's note: Listed under the Keefer Lodge.

Wrigley-Henderson Amalgamated British Columbia Directory, p. 72

1930

No job on this line: the 1930 directory prints work in its name section, under Watts (near p. 225), Urdal (near p. 203), Caldwell (near p. 100), Belton (near p. 47), Dennis (near p. 181), O'Brien (near p. 18) and Williams (near p. 244).

The dash (—) is printed in the directory where a first name would go: it gives none.

Wrigley's British Columbia Directory, p. 98

1935

No job on this line: the 1935 directory prints work in its name section, under Flynn (near p. 199).

British Columbia and Yukon Directory, p. 88

1945
  • Keefer Lodge roomsrooming house

British Columbia and Yukon Directory, p. 85

1955
  • a household
  • aKeefer Lodge roomsrooming house
  • aa household
  • ba household

4 listings. Names of residents after 1945 aren't shown; businesses and buildings are.

Vancouver and New Westminster City Directory, p. 131

Quote this house

One line with its source, for a listing, a talk or a family tree. A link to this page shows the card below wherever it's shared.

558 Keefer Street, Strathcona, Vancouver, is in the city directories from 1912 to 1955; the Williams name is listed there from 1925 to 1930. The building there today dates from 1963, by the City's record.

Source: AddressLore, addresslore.com/house/558-keefer, from Vancouver's city directories (Vancouver Public Library) and City of Vancouver open data.

Download the share card

The share card for 558 Keefer Street

The history of

558Keefer Street

Strathcona, 1912–1955

A PDF to keep, print or give

The book of 558 Keefer Street

This house as a book

Everything this page holds about 558 Keefer Street, gathered into one book: a chapter for each household, the block, the 1912 plate where there is one, and the page behind every line. To read here or save as a PDF to print or give.

Its contents

  1. The house
  2. Plate I, the house in an archive photoMarch 1974
  3. IVacant store1912
  4. IIThe McPhees1913
  5. IIIThe Trollopes1915
  6. IVKeefer Rooms1920
  7. The 1921 census1921
  8. VKeefer Lodge1925–1930
  9. Also at this address1930
  10. The 1931 census1931
  11. VIThe Flynns1935
  12. VIIKeefer Lodge1940–1945
  13. After 19451955
  14. The 500 block, decade by decade1905–1955
  15. Plate II, the 1912 fire insurance map1912
  16. The house today
  17. Sources, page by page

Open the book

Sources

Henderson's and successor city directories for Vancouver, 1905–1955, street sections, read line by line and checked against the scan (Vancouver Public Library, BC City Directories and UBC Library Open Collections, BC Historical Books); each year in the record links its page. Today's buildings: City of Vancouver Open Data (property tax report 2026, property addresses, Vancouver Heritage Register; Open Government Licence – Vancouver). The City's year built is BC Assessment's figure and can be approximate for old houses. Building permit: Heritage Vancouver Society's transcription of the City's permit registers, 1901–1930 (Historical Vancouver Building Permits; search it for this address). The 1921 census: Library and Archives Canada, Census of Canada, 1921, population schedule, read by us for addresses and counts, with names from Library and Archives Canada's index of it; a household tied to this address by inference is marked inferred. The 1931 census: Library and Archives Canada, Census of Canada, 1931, population schedule, read by us for addresses and counts; a household tied to this address by inference is marked inferred. The photo of the house: City of Vancouver Archives, copyright City of Vancouver, credited under it. Filed under this address at the City of Vancouver Archives: [558 Keefer Street], Mar. 1974 (CVA 1095-02509; photo, the photo on this page). Something wrong, or a name you'd like removed? Tell us.