The book of 558 Keefer Street, to read here or save as a PDF. Back to its page.

A house biography

558 Keefer Street

Strathcona, Vancouver
1912–1955

558 Keefer Street

Who lived there from 1912 to 1955, read line by line from Vancouver's city directories, with the page behind every line

Contents

  1. The house
  2. Plate I, the house in an archive photoMarch 1974
  3. Before the first listing1905 to 1911
  4. IVacant store1912
  5. IIThe McPhees1913
  6. IIIThe Trollopes1915
  7. IVKeefer Rooms1920
  8. The 1921 census1921
  9. VKeefer Lodge1925–1930
  10. Also at this address1930
  11. The 1931 census1931
  12. VIThe Flynns1935
  13. VIIKeefer Lodge1940–1945
  14. After 19451955
  15. The 500 block, decade by decade1905–1955
  16. Plate II, the 1912 fire insurance map1912
  17. The house today
  18. Sources, page by page

AddressLore, Vancouver, 2026

Prologue

The house

Three named households between 1913 and 1935: John McPhee, Harry Trollope and Mrs M Flynn. The 1930 name section gives James Dennis, a driver, at this address (page 181), matched to the 1930 listing here by first name or initials (inferred). It is also listed as Vacant store (1912), Keefer Rooms (1920), Keefer Lodge (1925–1930) and Keefer Lodge (1940–1945).

A permit to build brick stores was taken out in November 1910 by T W Hemphill, owner and builder: $5,000.

Where the directory printed “Japanese”, its canvassers wrote a group label in place of the residents' names; we show what was printed, and the names it never recorded we can't give.

Plate I

The building at 558 Keefer Street, three storeys with stacked bay windows over a ground floor with two doors, cars at the curb
March 1974 The building at 558 Keefer Street, three storeys with stacked bay windows over a ground floor with two doors, cars at the curb. Taken after the years the directories here cover; the house may have changed since. City of Vancouver Archives, CVA 1095-02509. Copyright City of Vancouver.

Before the first listing

1905 to 1911: the address is not listed in the directories.

Chapter I

Vacant store

as the directory lists it

In 1912 it is listed as Vacant store.

1912

The directory lists Vacant store here, with one listing under it.

Street section, as printed

  • Vacant storebusiness
  • Keefer Rooms

Chapter II

The McPhees

the household, 1913

By 1913 a household is listed here, John McPhee, one of two listings there.

1913

The directory lists Keefer Rooms here, with one listing under it.

Street section, as printed

  • McPhee John
  • Keefer Rooms

Chapter III

The Trollopes

the household, 1915

In 1915, after the McPhee household, the number has Harry Trollope, one of two listings there.

1915

Street section, as printed

  • Keefer Roomsrooming house
  • Trollope Harry

Chapter IV

Keefer Rooms

as the directory lists it

After the Trollope household, in 1920 it is listed as Keefer Rooms.

1920

Street section, as printed

  • Keefer Rooms
  • Vacant storebusiness

June 1, 1921

The 1921 census

Library and Archives Canada, the population schedule

On June 1, 1921, the census found nine households here, 22 people in all (eight of the nine households inferred: the census marks the street with a ditto, so we took it from the line above). Of them, eight rented, most at $7.50 a month. Most had one or two rooms. The census lists it as an apartment house.

Origin, as the census gave it: 22 Japanese. Where they were born: 16 in Japan and six in British Columbia.

The 18 people the census names here
The Tavakes, three people, renting
One lodger
The Baginskis, three people, renting
The Wakanoras, three people, renting
The Kitamuras, two people, renting
The Kates, two people, renting
The Skerns, three people, renting
The Ischalkies, one person, renting

One of the households here isn't named. We name a household only where Library and Archives Canada's index of the page agrees with our reading of it on every line: the same number of people, each related to the head the same way.

Origins are the census's own words, some no longer used. Names and relationships are as Library and Archives Canada's index of the census gives them; each links to its record there. Library and Archives Canada, Census of Canada, 1921 (RG31, Statistics Canada fonds), Vancouver Centre (district 22), sub-district 63, pages 29 and 30.

Chapter V

Keefer Lodge

9 to 10 listings a year

From 1925 to 1930 it is a building of suites or rooms, Keefer Lodge, with 9 to 10 listings a year.

1925

The directory lists Keefer Lodge here, with eight listings under it.

Reader's note: Listed under the Keefer Lodge.

Street section, as printed

  • Keefer Lodgerooming house
  • 1Brown G
  • 2Williams W G
  • 3“Japanese”
  • 4Scriber —
  • 5Otto L
  • 6“Japanese”
  • 7Harrison J
  • 8Hjorthoy H

1930

The name section gives the householder as James Dennis, a driver.

Street section, as printed

  • Keefer Lodge
  • 1Watts C
  • 2Urdal —
  • 3vacant
  • 4Caldwell Mrs M
  • 5Belton J
  • 6vacant
  • 7Dennis J
  • 8O'Brien —
  • 9Williams W J

Name section, as printed

Dennis Jas drvr h 7, 558 Keefer

1930

Also at this address

from the name section

The 1930 name section gives this address for Herbert O'Brien, a grader at the City of Vancouver, under a surname no household here was listed under. The directory doesn't say whether this person boarded, rented a room or was family.

1930

Name section, as printed

O'Brien Herbt grader Van City h 8, 558 Keefer

June 1, 1931

The 1931 census

Library and Archives Canada, the population schedule

On June 1, 1931, ten years on, the census found one household here: 20 people, renting at $40 a month, in nine rooms (inferred: the census writes the street once and the numbers under it, so we matched this number to that street). The census lists it as a single house, built of wood.

Origins in 1931: nine English, four Norwegian, two Swedish, one French, one Irish, one Italian, one Spanish and one not given or not readable. Their birthplaces: nine in British Columbia, two in England, two in Norway, two in Sweden, one in France, one in Ireland, one in Italy, one in New Zealand and one elsewhere.

Library and Archives Canada, Census of Canada, 1931 (RG31, Statistics Canada fonds), Vancouver Centre (electoral district 236), sub-district 38 (record 85907530), page 25, line 7.

Chapter VI

The Flynns

the household, 1935

1935 brings Mrs M Flynn.

1935

The directory lists Keefer Lodge rooms here, with one listing under it.

Street section, as printed

  • Flynn Mrs M
  • Keefer Lodge roomsrooming house

Chapter VII

Keefer Lodge

as the directory lists it

After the Flynn household, from 1940 to 1945 it is listed as Keefer Lodge.

1940

Street section, as printed

  • Keefer Lodgerooms

1945

The directory lists Keefer Lodge rooms here.

Street section, as printed

  • Keefer Lodge roomsrooming house

After 1945

How the address was used

After 1945 this edition says how the address was used, not who lived there: names of residents after 1945 aren't shown, and anyone can ask for a name to be removed.

1955

Four listings, none with work printed.

The street

The 500 block, decade by decade

Keefer Street, Strathcona, every door the directories list

1905

One door listed and one shop or business.

North side

  1. 535Lord Strathcona School, institution

Street section, p. 73

1906

One door listed and one shop or business.

North side

  1. 535Lord Strathcona School

Street section, p. 100

1907

One door listed and one shop or business.

North side

  1. 535Lord Strathcona School

Street section, p. 211

1908

Three doors listed and one shop or business.

North side

  1. 535Lord Strathcona School

South side

  1. 520New house
  2. 540New house

Street section, p. 289, p. 291

1909

Five doors listed and one shop or business.

North side

  1. 535Strathcona School

South side

  1. 518Wilbur Captain H V
  2. 522Young Capt Henry A
  3. 532Brown Frederick J, pilot
  4. 542Campbell Thomas

Street section, p. 356, p. 358

1910

Eight doors listed and two shops and businesses.

North side

  1. 535Strathcona School

South side

  1. 518Wilbur Captain H V
  2. 522Young Capt Henry A
  3. 524Bradley Edward, grocer
  4. 526Thompson Robert, lineman
  5. 532Brown Frederick J, pilot
  6. 534McGann Frank, waiter
  7. 542Campbell Thomas

Street section, p. 128, p. 130

1911

Eight doors listed and one shop or business.

North side

  1. 535Strathcona School

South side

  1. 518Wilbur Captain H V
  2. 522Young Capt Henry A
  3. 524Bradley Edward
  4. 532Brown Frederick J
  5. 534Mohrman Oscar
  6. 536McGann Frank
  7. 542Cima Pietro

Street section, p. 345, p. 346

1912

Twelve doors listed and four shops and businesses.

North side

  1. 535Strathcona School

South side

  1. 510Banff Rooms
  2. 514Union Men's Assoc
  3. 518Wilbur Captain H V
  4. 522Young Capt Henry A
  5. 524Bradley Edw
  6. 526Warren Leslie
  7. 532Brown Fred J
  8. 534Mohrman Oscar
  9. 536McGann Frank
  10. 542Cima Pietro
  11. 558Vacant store, business and one more

Street section, p. 87, p. 88

1913

Twelve doors listed, four shops and businesses and one vacant.

North side

  1. 535Strathcona School

South side

  1. 510Nugget Rooms
  2. 514Meater & Son
  3. 518Kellberg Eric
  4. 522Ryall Sarah
  5. 524Bradley Edw
  6. 526Warren Leslie
  7. 532Anthony Mary A
  8. 534Mohrman Oscar
  9. 536vacant
  10. 542Cima Pietro
  11. 558Keefer Rooms and one more

Street section, p. 109, p. 110

1915

Twelve doors listed, three shops and businesses and one printed with a group label instead of names.

North side

  1. 535Strathcona School, institution

South side

  1. 510Tennant Andw
  2. 514Chinese Mission, institution
  3. 518Kellberg Eric
  4. 522Rudd Hans
  5. 524Bradley Edw
  6. 526Wallings Morley A
  7. 532“Chinese”
  8. 536Mohrman Oscar
  9. 542Cima Pietro, confectioner
  10. 558Keefer Rooms, rooming house and one more
  11. 568Lawrence Jennie

Street section, p. 98, p. 99

1920

Twelve doors listed, two shops and businesses, four vacant and two printed with a group label instead of names.

North side

  1. 535Strathcona School

South side

  1. 510vacant
  2. 514vacant
  3. 518Kellberg Eric
  4. 522Battello Mrs Cecilia
  5. 524vacant
  6. 526vacant
  7. 532“Chinese”
  8. 536“Chinese”
  9. 542Cima Pietro
  10. 558Keefer Rooms and one more
  11. 568Sun Lum Wah

Street section, p. 86, p. 87

1925

15 doors listed, two shops and businesses, one vacant and eight printed with a group label instead of names.

North side

  1. 535Strathcona Sch, institution

South side

  1. 510Yeoman J
  2. 514Goldberg —
  3. 518Mandleman J
  4. 522“Chinese”
  5. 524“Chinese”
  6. 526vacant
  7. 532“Chinese”
  8. 536“Chinese”
  9. 542Cima P
  10. 546“Chinese”
  11. 548“Chinese”
  12. 558Keefer Lodge, rooming house and eight more
  13. 560Ganter C
  14. 568“Chinese”

Street section, p. 71, p. 72

1930

14 doors listed, three shops and businesses, one vacant and six printed with a group label instead of names.

South side

  1. 510Excelsior Apts
  2. 514Golberg J (Whse)
  3. 518Mandleman J
  4. 522Pulice F
  5. 524Rooks C
  6. 526“Oriental”
  7. 532“Orientals”
  8. 536“Orientals”
  9. 542Cima P
  10. 546“Orientals”
  11. 548“Orientals” and one more
  12. 558Keefer Lodge and nine more
  13. 560vacant
  14. 568“Orientals”

Street section, p. 98

1935

15 doors listed, three shops and businesses, two vacant and five printed with a group label instead of names.

North side

  1. 535Strathcona Sch, institution

South side

  1. 510Excelsior Apts rooms, rooming house
  2. 514vacant
  3. 518*Mandleman J
  4. 522Johnson E
  5. 524Fong W
  6. 526“Orientals”
  7. 532Glowsky S
  8. 536“Orientals”
  9. 542*Cima P
  10. 546“Orientals”
  11. 548“Orientals” and one more
  12. 558Keefer Lodge rooms, rooming house and one more
  13. 560vacant
  14. 568“Orientals”

Street section, p. 88

1940

Twelve doors listed, two shops and businesses, one vacant and three printed with a group label instead of names.

South side

  1. 510*Excelsior Apt, rooms to let and one more
  2. 514vacant
  3. 518*Babaval J
  4. 522Lundvall E
  5. 524Wing Fong and three more
  6. 532Glowsky S
  7. 536“Orientals”
  8. 542*Zagar M
  9. 546“Orientals”
  10. 548Sam H and one more
  11. 558Keefer Lodge, rooms to let
  12. 568Hong J

Street section, p. 93

1945

Twelve doors listed, three shops and businesses and two printed with a group label instead of names.

South side

  1. 510Excelsior Rooms & Apts, rooming house
  2. 514Goldberg J (whse)
  3. 518*Babaval J, rooms to let
  4. 522Lundvall E
  5. 524Chow H
  6. 532Lum Fon
  7. 536Jang Kee Shew
  8. 542“Orientals”
  9. 546“Orientals”
  10. 548Sam H and one more
  11. 558Keefer Lodge rooms, rooming house
  12. 568Sun Lok Moy

Street section, p. 85

1955

14 doors listed and three shops and businesses. Names after 1945 aren't shown.

North side

  1. 535*Strathcona Sch, institution

South side

  1. 510Excelsior Rooms, rooming house
  2. 514Lions Gate Moving & Stge, business and one more
  3. 518*a household · rooms to let
  4. 522a household
  5. 524a household · pedlar and two more
  6. 532*a household
  7. 536*a household
  8. 542*a household
  9. 546*a household
  10. 548*a household
  11. 558a household and three more
  12. 564a household and one more
  13. 568a household

Street section, p. 131

Who stayed on the 500 block: of the addresses with a named household in both directories, how many still had the same surname in the next directory we've read. A filled house kept its family.

Plate II

The lot at 558 Keefer Street on the 1912 fire insurance map
558 Keefer Street on Goad's 1912 map. Goad's Fire Insurance Map, 1912, georectified by the City of Vancouver (Open Government Licence – Vancouver). The circle marks the address.

Epilogue

The house today

The address is still in use, but the City's record dates the building to 1963: the house in these directories is gone.

Since 1955

  1. 1963Today's building goes up, by the City's record.
  2. 1968The south side of the 500 block of Keefer Street is inside the boundary of the City's Urban Renewal Scheme 3 (Strathcona I). The boundary alone doesn't say which blocks were to be cleared. (LEG37.28, dated Aug. 1968)

From City of Vancouver open data (Open Government Licence – Vancouver): the property tax report (BC Assessment's years, approximate for old buildings), business licences from 1997 (the kind of business only), issued building permits from 2017 and the heritage register. The urban-renewal plans: City of Vancouver Archives, each record linked on its line; the plans and maps are under the City's copyright, so we tell what they show and don't reproduce them.

The directories in this book stop in 1955; names are shown through 1945. What they printed at 558 Keefer Street is in the chapters before this one, every line with its page, so anyone can check it.

Sources

The page behind every line

Every year here comes from that year's printed city directory, held by the Vancouver Public Library. Canvassers compiled each one door to door, so a listing is who they recorded at the door, not a legal record of who owned or rented the house. Names are copied as printed, spellings and all. The street section lists each address in order; the name section lists each person with their work and address, which is where the jobs come from. h marks a householder, r someone living there, wid a widow. *: some member of the family owns the property, to the best of the directory's knowledge (its own mark, printed from 1935).

Anything we infer (a likely build date, a misprinted number, a renumbered address) is marked as inferred. Names are shown up to 1945; later years say only how the address was used. We link the library's page images and never reprint them.

Pages cited

  1. 1905Henderson's City of Vancouver Directory: street section p. 73
  2. 1906Henderson's City of Vancouver Directory: street section p. 100
  3. 1907Henderson's City of Vancouver Directory: street section p. 211
  4. 1908Henderson's City of Vancouver Directory: street section p. 289, p. 291
  5. 1909Henderson's City of Vancouver Directory: street section p. 356, p. 358
  6. 1910Henderson's City of Vancouver and North Vancouver Directory Part 1: street section p. 128, p. 130
  7. 1911Henderson's Greater Vancouver New Westminster and Fraser Valley Directory: street section p. 345, p. 346
  8. 1912Henderson's Greater Vancouver Directory Part 1: street section p. 87, p. 88
  9. 1913Henderson's Greater Vancouver City Directory Part 1: street section p. 109, p. 110
  10. 1915Henderson's Greater Vancouver City Directory: street section p. 98, p. 99
  11. 1920Henderson's Vancouver Directory: street section p. 86, p. 87
  12. 1925Wrigley-Henderson Amalgamated British Columbia Directory: street section p. 71, p. 72
  13. 1930Wrigley's British Columbia Directory: street section p. 98; name section p. 19, p. 181
  14. 1935British Columbia and Yukon Directory: street section p. 88
  15. 1940British Columbia and Yukon Directory: street section p. 93
  16. 1945British Columbia and Yukon Directory: street section p. 85
  17. 1955Vancouver and New Westminster City Directory: street section p. 131

The 1912 map: Goad's Fire Insurance Map, georectified by the City of Vancouver. Today's buildings, the heritage register and the years since 1955: City of Vancouver open data. Both under the Open Government Licence – Vancouver. The photograph: City of Vancouver Archives, CVA 1095-02509, copyright City of Vancouver. The 1921 census: Library and Archives Canada, Census of Canada, 1921, population schedule, read by us for addresses and counts, with names from Library and Archives Canada's index of it; a household tied to this address by inference is marked inferred. The 1931 census: Library and Archives Canada, Census of Canada, 1931, population schedule, read by us for addresses and counts; a household tied to this address by inference is marked inferred.

Something wrong, or a name you'd like removed? Tell us.

Compiled by AddressLore, Vancouver, November 2026. Set in Libre Caslon.

A house biography

Your house

Vancouver, from the city directories

A PDF to keep, print or give

Another address?

Every house has its book

    Find yours by its address: