Kitsilano, Vancouver

2191 West 1st Avenue

In the 1935, 1940 and 1945 city directories, of the nine we've read for West 1st Avenue.

In 1935, the address is Efilda Apartments. In 1945, 2191 West 1st Avenue is Croydon Apartments, with 15 suites and households listed under it. The street section prints 15 names: M Taylor, Mrs I J McIntosh and 13 others.

Open this house's bookIts history laid out as a book, chapter by chapter, each line with its page, to read here or save as a PDF to print or give.

15
people the 1945 directory lists here
First listed 1935
the 1905 directory lists the block but not 2191 (a hint the building came later)
Still standing
today, by the City's records
1931
the year built, by the City's record

When was it built

Probably built about 1930–1931: the records below agree. (inferred)

  1. 1930A building permit is taken out.
  2. 1931The City's record gives this as the year built. It is BC Assessment's figure, and can be approximate for an old house.
  3. 1935First listed in the directories.

In 1905

The 1905 directory lists West 1st Avenue but not 2191.

West 1st Avenue is read from the 1905 directory's street section, line by line. The 1905 directory prints it as West Front Street; its numbers run along today's West 1st Avenue, so we take them for one street (inferred).

In 1910

The 1910 directory lists West 1st Avenue but not 2191.

West 1st Avenue is read from the 1910 directory, street by street and by name, line by line. The 1910 directory prints it as West Front Street; its numbers run along today's West 1st Avenue, so we take them for one street (inferred).

In 1915

The 1915 directory lists West 1st Avenue but not 2191.

West 1st Avenue is read from the 1915 directory's street section, line by line. The 1915 directory prints it as West Front Street; its numbers run along today's West 1st Avenue, so we take them for one street (inferred).

In 1920

The 1920 directory lists West 1st Avenue but not 2191.

West 1st Avenue is read from the 1920 directory, street by street and by name, line by line. The 1920 directory prints it as West Front Street; its numbers run along today's West 1st Avenue, so we take them for one street (inferred).

In 1925

The 1925 directory lists West 1st Avenue but not 2191.

West 1st Avenue is read from the 1925 directory's street section, line by line.

In 1930

The 1930 directory lists West 1st Avenue but not 2191.

West 1st Avenue is read from the 1930 directory, street by street and by name, line by line.

In 1935

The street section

  • 15 linesEfilda Apartments and its suites and households, each on the page beside

Only in the street section

West 1st Avenue is read from the 1935 directory's street section, line by line.

The lines for 2191 West 1st Avenue in the 1935 directory, as we read them, with its abbreviations; each opens its page at the Vancouver Public Library.

In 1940

The street section

  • 15 linesCroydon Apartments and its suites and households, each on the page beside

The household

  • George W Churtona salesman at White Distributor · householder · suite 10p. 110
  • Charles E Cooka manager at the Croydon Apartments · householder · suite 1p. 124
  • A Howard Garlanda salesman at Canada Cycle & Motor · householder · suite 12p. 216
  • Wilfred L Grahama branch manager at Tip Top Tailors · householder · suite 4p. 234
  • Ormond St C Harrisa president at Harris Lumber and Shuswap Lumber · householder · suite 8p. 256
  • William Jacksonretired · householder · suite 15p. 299
  • Jane Kiddwidow of D Kidd · householderp. 322
  • Mrs Ina J McIntoshhouseholder · suite 2p. 380
  • Alfred A Mandelslowa manager at Cylinder Grinders · householder · suite 5p. 409
  • Ray D O'Conneran engineer · householder · suite 6p. 467
  • Frank M Paintera school teacher · householder · suite 9p. 477
  • W Cecil Wakelya canvasser for Ceperley Rounsefell · householder · suite 7p. 636

Only in the street section

Also at this address

  • Keelinga widow · householder · suite 1Ap. 316
  • Isabelle Trainwidow of J Train · lives here · suite 2p. 617
  • Elsie Jacksonlives here · suite 15p. 298

West 1st Avenue is read from the 1940 directory, street by street and by name, line by line.

The lines for 2191 West 1st Avenue in the 1940 directory, as we read them, with its abbreviations; each opens its page at the Vancouver Public Library. The name section prints h for a householder and r for someone who lives at the address.

In 1945

The street section

  • 16 linesCroydon Apartments and its suites and households, each on the page beside

Only in the street section

West 1st Avenue is read from the 1945 directory's street section, line by line.

The lines for 2191 West 1st Avenue in the 1945 directory, as we read them, with its abbreviations; each opens its page at the Vancouver Public Library.

The building today

2191 West 1st Avenue still has a building from before 1946, one of three on the block; its permit is from 1930, and the City's assessment record gives 1931 as its year built. A building permit was taken out in November 1930 by H W Retallack, owner and builder: architect Thomas Carmichael, $50,000.

Since 1945

  1. 1997–2024Licensed as an apartment house (licences on record start in 1997).

From City of Vancouver open data (Open Government Licence – Vancouver): the property tax report (BC Assessment's years, approximate for old buildings), business licences from 1997 (the kind of business only), issued building permits from 2017 and the heritage register.

To go further on when it was built and by whom: search the City's permit registers for 2191 in Heritage Vancouver's transcription, 1901–1930, and ask the City of Vancouver Archives for its water service records, since a house usually applied for water as it was finished. Our guide has the steps.

The 2100 block, year by year

West 1st Avenue between Arbutus and Yew Streets, Kitsilano: every door each year we've read lists on the block, the way it prints them, and what stands at each today. This house is marked in red. Pick a year to read who lived at every door.

West 1st Avenue, the 2100 blockas the 1945 directory lists it, door by door, and what stands there today

*: some member of the family owns the property, to the best of the directory's knowledge (its own mark, printed from 1935)

North side, odd numbers

  1. 2105Wallace W H*Wallace W HPhillip A PHill C Wgone
  2. 2115Valleau Frederick WValleau Fred WPorter Norman RPickup Mrs ETretheway CWill Mrs S Avacant*Rochon G Jrebuilt
  3. 2117Mutch SHillier Lewis GHillier Lewis GMcMillan AvacantUpham CUpham C*Upham Crebuilt
  4. 2123Lang Warren HBurch Rev Arthur LJeffares Geo WHeasman CvacantTaylor R C*Taylor R C*Taylor R Cgone
  5. 2125Pope Johnnot listednot listednot listednot listednot listednot listednot listedgone
  6. 2127Pope John CPope John CPope J CvacantBurns Mrs M*Neilly Mrs E P*Neilly Mrs E Pgone
  7. 2129Morley John Hnot listednot listednot listednot listednot listednot listednot listedgone
  8. 2137Ogilvie WmCinci AntonioMcIntyre Henry BMcIntyre H BMcIntyre H BMatthias A EYorkshire Chimney Sweep +1*Bowes H Srebuilt
  9. 2143Tillerdale Arthur RPalmer RobtEastley Thos BJames G LvacantBalkom E JLaity R RDe Gryp Agone
  10. 2147Gray DorionGray Dorion WCampbell Harold BHungerford S WWallace J D*Hungerford S W*Hungerford S W*Meredith W Hgone
  11. 2151Davies M Bvacantvacantnot listednot listednot listednot listednot listedgone
  12. 2155Schwengers AlicevacantvacantLand J +7Helens Court +7Helens Court +6Helens Court +7Helen's Court +7gone
  13. 2159vacantvacantvacantnot listednot listednot listednot listednot listedgone
  14. 2171Hope F H WFreeman Chas BFreeman Chas Bvacantvacant*Draper W H +2Crowe M +2Crowe M +2rebuilt
  15. 2173vacant +1Chapman C +1McKillop Miss Z +1gone
  16. 2191Efilda Apts +14Croydon Apts +14Croydon Apts +15stands

South side, even numbers

  1. 2100Caldwell JamesCaldwell JamesRodway JosephWright JStewart C*Lea F Cvacant*Burton Ngone
  2. 2116Lamont James FLamont James FLamont J FPearson E +1McDonald L WSparkes R W +1Gray J Jstands
  3. 2124Cunningham, JamesSuggitt Samuel ESuggitt Saml TSuggitt Saml TSuggitt S TSuggitt S T*Suggitt S T*Suggit S TUtas J Agone
  4. 2130occupied, no name givenLake FrankLawrance Fredk GFaulkner J WFaulkner J W*Faulkner J W*Faulkner J W*Duncan R Agone
  5. 2136Hillman JosephHillman JosephHillman JosephHillman JHill J SvacantHuish ARawnsley H R +1rebuilt
  6. 2146Martin Henry SvacantCalderbank Geo EPalmer RMcKinnon J Doccupied, no name givenColeman J*Wheelwright Mrs S Jstands
  7. 2150Churchill, IsaacvacantEngvick Alvin JHoffmeister LouisHoffmeister L GHoffmeister L G*Hoffmeister L G*Hoffmeister L G*Edwards Mrs Mrebuilt
  8. 2158Crane, George H.Larson Anders MLarson Andw MLarson Andw MLarson A MLarson Mrs E*Larson Mrs E*Larson Mrs E*Larson Mrs Egone
  9. 2168vacantGoddard Joseph AGoddard Joseph AKay John S“Japanese”vacantKudo FMacready WEllison F Jgone
  10. 2172Murray RobertMurray RobtMurray RobtMurray RMurray R*Murray R*Murray R*Murray R Fgone
  11. 2176Smith, William ChalmerHorner S ABlack James ADevelin Harry FManderville LHingley WHatch R*Manderville Mrs M L*Evans Mrs P +1gone
  12. 2182Shaw Wm AShaw Wm AToff Mrs MaryKirk Mrs LSmith R RMacready W*Kirk A*Kirk Agone
  13. 2192McKay, Chas.vacantnot listednot listednot listednot listednot listednot listednot listedgone
Who stayed on the 2100 block: of the addresses with a named household in both years, how many had the same surname in the later one. A filled house kept its family.

The 2100 block of West 1st Avenue

Quote this house

One line with its source, for a listing, a talk or a family tree. A link to this page shows the card below wherever it's shared.

2191 West 1st Avenue, Kitsilano, Vancouver, is in the 1935, 1940 and 1945 city directories. A building from before 1946 still stands there: the City's record gives 1931 as the year built.

Source: AddressLore, addresslore.com/house/2191-west-1st-avenue, from Vancouver's city directories (Vancouver Public Library) and City of Vancouver open data.

Download the share card

The share card for 2191 West 1st Avenue

The book of 2191 West 1st Avenue

This address as a book

Everything this page holds about 2191 West 1st Avenue, gathered into one book with the page behind every line, to read here or save as a PDF to print or give. As we read more directory years for this street, the book grows with them.

Open the book

Sources

The city directories of 1905 (Henderson's City of Vancouver Directory), 1910 (Henderson's City of Vancouver and North Vancouver Directory Part 1), 1915 (Henderson's Greater Vancouver City Directory), 1920 (Henderson's Vancouver Directory), 1925 (Wrigley-Henderson Amalgamated British Columbia Directory), 1930 (Wrigley's British Columbia Directory), 1935 (British Columbia and Yukon Directory), 1940 (British Columbia and Yukon Directory) and 1945 (British Columbia and Yukon Directory), street and name sections where both are read, read line by line and checked against the scan (Vancouver Public Library, BC City Directories); each line above links its page. Today's buildings: City of Vancouver Open Data (property tax report 2026, property addresses, Vancouver Heritage Register; Open Government Licence – Vancouver). The City's year built is BC Assessment's figure and can be approximate for old houses. Building permit: Heritage Vancouver Society's transcription of the City's permit registers, 1901–1930 (Historical Vancouver Building Permits; search it for this address). Something wrong, or a name you'd like removed? Tell us.