West Point Grey, Vancouver

4654 West 10th Avenue

In the 1920 and 1930 city directories, of the nine we've read for West 10th Avenue.

Samuel J Montgomery is the first listed here, in 1920. Sam J Montgomery, a secretary at the Board of Works Vancouver City, shared 4654 West 10th Avenue in 1930 with one person under another surname. The later directories we've read, 1935 to 1945, list West 10th Avenue but not 4654.

Open this house's bookIts history laid out as a book, chapter by chapter, each line with its page, to read here or save as a PDF to print or give.

The 1920 and 1930 directories print this house as 4654 West Broadway: nearly every number they give there sits on today's West 10th Avenue, so we take them for one street (inferred).

2
people the 1930 directory lists here
Address gone
today, by the City's records

In 1905

The 1905 directory lists West 10th Avenue but not 4654.

West 10th Avenue is read from the 1905 directory's street section, line by line.

In 1910

The 1910 directory lists West 10th Avenue but not 4654.

West 10th Avenue is read from the 1910 directory, street by street and by name, line by line.

In 1915

The 1915 directory lists West 10th Avenue but not 4654.

West 10th Avenue is read from the 1915 directory's street section, line by line.

In 1920

The street section

West 10th Avenue is read from the 1920 directory, street by street and by name, line by line. The 1920 directory prints it as part of West Broadway; nearly every number it gives there sits on today's West 10th Avenue, so we take them for one street (inferred).

1920Henderson's Vancouver Directory

Streets

WEST BROADWAY

  1. 4654Montgomery Saml Jp. 18
The lines for 4654 West 10th Avenue, printed as 4654 West Broadway, in the 1920 directory, as we read them, with its abbreviations; each opens its page at the Vancouver Public Library.

In 1925

The 1925 directory lists West 10th Avenue but not 4654.

West 10th Avenue is read from the 1925 directory's street section, line by line.

In 1930

The household

  • Sam J Montgomerya secretary at the Board of Works Vancouver City · householderp. 513

Also at this address

  • Margaret Geddeslives herep. 253

West 10th Avenue is read from the 1930 directory, street by street and by name, line by line. The 1930 directory prints it as part of West Broadway; nearly every number it gives there sits on today's West 10th Avenue, so we take them for one street (inferred).

The lines for 4654 West 10th Avenue, printed as 4654 West Broadway, in the 1930 directory, as we read them, with its abbreviations; each opens its page at the Vancouver Public Library. The name section prints h for a householder and r for someone who lives at the address.

In 1935

The 1935 directory lists West 10th Avenue but not 4654.

West 10th Avenue is read from the 1935 directory's street section, line by line.

In 1940

The 1940 directory lists West 10th Avenue but not 4654.

West 10th Avenue is read from the 1940 directory, street by street and by name, line by line.

In 1945

The 1945 directory lists West 10th Avenue but not 4654.

West 10th Avenue is read from the 1945 directory's street section, line by line.

The house today

The City's list of addresses no longer has 4654 West 10th Avenue, so the building is probably gone (inferred); nothing on the 4600 block of West 10th Avenue stands from before 1946: three doors along, 4660 has a building from 1970.

To go further on when it was built and by whom: search the City's permit registers for 4654 in Heritage Vancouver's transcription, 1901–1930, and ask the City of Vancouver Archives for its water service records, since a house usually applied for water as it was finished. Our guide has the steps.

The 4600 block, year by year

West 10th Avenue starting at Tolmie Street, West Point Grey: every door each year we've read lists on the block, the way it prints them, and what stands at each today. This house is marked in red. Pick a year to read who lived at every door.

West 10th Avenue, the 4600 blockas the 1945 directory lists it, door by door, and what stands there today

*: some member of the family owns the property, to the best of the directory's knowledge (its own mark, printed from 1935)

The 1905 directory lists no one on this block.

The 1910 directory lists no one on this block.

The 1915 directory lists no one on this block.

North side, odd numbers

  1. 4601Munro W SMunro Mrs C RMunro Mrs C RMunro Mrs C Rgone
  2. 4603Louise MadameHemming & Son +1West Pt Grey Library +1West Pt Grey Library +1gone
  3. 4605Avis C E +1Fraser A M +1Harold's Dairy +1Rose Cgone
  4. 4607Sasamat Beauty ShoppeVarsity Rentery +1Varsity Rentery +1Williamson T Hgone
  5. 4609vacantIrvine W AGateway Gro +1Gateway Gro +1gone
  6. 4615St Lawrence Tnot listednot listednot listedrebuilt
  7. 4623Burgess Mrs EMcGuigan W J*Manning V Z*Manning V Zgone
  8. 4625Stacey L Bnot listednot listednot listedgone
  9. 4629Bennett J Constn Co LtdBennett J Constn CoHow Mrs M JHow Miss M Igone
  10. 4633Ciro A*Ciro A*Ciro A*Ciro Agone
  11. 4635Hewer G Cnot listednot listednot listedgone
  12. 4639Hillier J H*Hillier J H*Hillier J H*Hillier J Hrebuilt
  13. 4643Bannister F RKlennan A B*Shannon Mrs L P*Shannon Mrs L Pgone
  14. 4645Bunting W Nnot listednot listednot listedgone
  15. 4649*Thompson R C*Found L R*Wilkinson Mrs Mgone
  16. 4653*Bennett J*Buck G Rgone
  17. 4659Redgate Mrs L Enot listednot listednot listedgone
  18. 4663Murray DonaldMurray DMundie G A +1*Murray DMilvain Mrs IMilvain Mrs Igone
  19. 4665*Williams H Vrebuilt
  20. 4669Sims H +1not listedSwitzer Rev J CSwitzer Mrs L Dgone
  21. 4673Sider LJohnston TJohnston TJohnston Tgone
  22. 4681Spiers A Cnot listednot listedFoulds R Pgone
  23. 4683Sims Harrynot listednot listednot listednot listednot listedgone
  24. 4685Hilchie W Fgone
  25. 4691Vaiu A Erebuilt
  26. 4693Lloyd Pnot listednot listednot listedgone
  27. 4695Ray Mrs Dgone

South side, even numbers

  1. 4606Eyre P Wnot listednot listednot listedgone
  2. 4608*Ivey C R +2*Ivey C R +1gone
  3. 4612Johnson A Hnot listednot listednot listedgone
  4. 4614*Green W Vgone
  5. 4620Spencer G JLobb J FMacaulay RMacaulay Rrebuilt
  6. 4624Browne S J +1*Browne S JFerries G FGoodman M H +1gone
  7. 4626Parmelee J Dnot listednot listednot listedgone
  8. 4630Scanlon JScanlon Jgone
  9. 4634Berry H Anot listedLee G McCMutch J McDgone
  10. 4640vacantnot listednot listednot listedrebuilt
  11. 4644Welch David WWelch J RWelsh J R*Welsh J R*Welsh J R*Welsh J Rgone
  12. 4648Thompson W G BWilliams N Knot listednot listedgone
  13. 4650Shill P Wgone
  14. 4652Croll Mrs Egone
  15. 4654Montgomery Saml Jnot listedMontgomery S Jnot listednot listednot listedgone
  16. 4656Melville C Mgone
  17. 4658Hooley J Ggone
  18. 4660De Long A Rnot listednot listednot listedrebuilt
  19. 4662Holland F Wgone
  20. 4664Forward Mrs Egone
  21. 4670Jackson Fred MJackson F MGermain H E WSwitzer J C +1*Jackson F M*Jackson F Mgone
  22. 4672Harkness Davidnot listedDaniels J Mnot listednot listednot listedgone
  23. 4674Henderson Mrs HSadler Mrs A BSadler Mrs A BPyle Miss E Cgone
  24. 4678Carson J Anot listednot listednot listedgone
  25. 4680McKinney J*McKinney Mrs E C*King W A*King W Agone
  26. 4684Watson J H +1not listedWilliams N KWilliams N Kgone
  27. 4690Hallum Wnot listednot listednot listedgone
  28. 4696Varsity Serv StaVarsity Serv StaVarsity Serv StaVarsity Serv Sta +1rebuilt
Who stayed on the 4600 block: of the addresses with a named household in both years, how many had the same surname in the later one. A filled house kept its family.

The 4600 block of West 10th Avenue

Quote this house

One line with its source, for a listing, a talk or a family tree. A link to this page shows the card below wherever it's shared.

4654 West 10th Avenue, West Point Grey, Vancouver, is in the 1920 and 1930 city directories. The City no longer lists the address.

Source: AddressLore, addresslore.com/house/4654-west-10th-avenue, from Vancouver's city directories (Vancouver Public Library) and City of Vancouver open data.

Download the share card

The share card for 4654 West 10th Avenue

The book of 4654 West 10th Avenue

This address as a book

Everything this page holds about 4654 West 10th Avenue, gathered into one book with the page behind every line, to read here or save as a PDF to print or give. As we read more directory years for this street, the book grows with them.

Open the book

Sources

The city directories of 1905 (Henderson's City of Vancouver Directory), 1910 (Henderson's City of Vancouver and North Vancouver Directory Part 1), 1915 (Henderson's Greater Vancouver City Directory), 1920 (Henderson's Vancouver Directory), 1925 (Wrigley-Henderson Amalgamated British Columbia Directory), 1930 (Wrigley's British Columbia Directory), 1935 (British Columbia and Yukon Directory), 1940 (British Columbia and Yukon Directory) and 1945 (British Columbia and Yukon Directory), street and name sections where both are read, read line by line and checked against the scan (Vancouver Public Library, BC City Directories); each line above links its page. Today's buildings: City of Vancouver Open Data (property tax report 2026, property addresses, Vancouver Heritage Register; Open Government Licence – Vancouver). The City's year built is BC Assessment's figure and can be approximate for old houses. Something wrong, or a name you'd like removed? Tell us.