A house biography
686 West Broadway
Fairview, Vancouver
1925–1945
686 West Broadway
Who lived there from 1925 to 1945, read line by line from Vancouver's city directories, with the page behind every line
Contents
- The house
- Before the first listing1905 to 1920
- IThe Hayses1925
- IIThe Robertshaws1930
- IIIThe McLaughlins1935
- IVWearwell Shoe Repairs1940
- VSally's Sewing Shop1945
- The 600 block, decade by decade1905–1945
- The house today
- Sources, page by page
AddressLore, Vancouver, 2026
Prologue
The house
Three households in three directories, 1925 to 1935, none of them listed twice; in 1935 W D McLaughlin shares the number with one other listing. It is also listed as Wearwell Shoe Repairs (1940) and Sally's Sewing Shop (1945).
Before the first listing
1905 to 1920: the address is not listed in the directories.
Chapter I
The Hayses
the household, 1925
L Hays lived at 686 West Broadway in 1925.
1925
Street section, as printed
- Hays L
Chapter II
The Robertshaws
the household, 1930
By 1930 A Robertshaw lived at 686 West Broadway. The 1930 name section doesn't list this household.
1930
Street section, as printed
- Robertshaw A
Chapter III
The McLaughlins
the household, 1935
In 1935, 686 West Broadway is Mack's Used Magazine Exchange, with one person listed under it. The street section prints one name: W D McLaughlin.
1935
Street section, as printed
- Mack's Used Magazine Exch
- McLaughlin W D
Chapter IV
Wearwell Shoe Repairs
as the directory lists it
In 1940, 686 West Broadway is Wearwell Shoe Repairs.
1940
Street section, as printed
- Wearwell Shoe Reprs
Chapter V
Sally's Sewing Shop
as the directory lists it
In 1945, 686 West Broadway is Sally's Sewing Shop.
1945
Street section, as printed
- Sally's Sewing Shop
The street
The 600 block, decade by decade
West Broadway, Fairview, every door the directories list
The Hays name moves along the block: here in 1925, then at 634 in 1930 (the same family, or another with the same surname: inferred).
1905
Eight doors listed and one shop or business.
North side
- 601Hogg, Alex., grocer
- 625New house
- 645New house
- 655Kay, John, miner
- 685Eldridge, George H., employee C. P. R
South side
- 622Jones, George C., machinist
- 664Hay, James, builder
- 690Fortin, Michael, sawyer
Street section, p. 80
1910
22 doors listed, five shops and businesses and one vacant.
North side
- 601Findlay David, grocer
- 623Morris George H, shoe store
- 625McKeating Patrick, laborer
- 645Martin James A, carpenter
- 655Douglas James McD, superintendent
- 665Murray James F
- 671Whyte David, retired
- 675Beckett Nathaniel J, bookkeeper
- 679Vincent Albert F
- 685Elvidge George H
South side
- 622Jones George C, machinist
- 626Midway Brokerage Co
- 628Demers Alfred, laundryman
- 632Kellas Peter, printer
- 646Reynolds Edward S
- 654Reid Jos A
- 664Munson Samuel F, real estate
- 676Burchell Edward, telephone operator
- 684Johnson George W, miller
- 690vacant
- 694The Square Grocery
- 698Cameron's Drug Store
Street section, p. 26
1915
32 doors listed, six shops and businesses and nine vacant.
North side
- 601McCannell Albt E, confectioner
- 603vacant
- 623Kay Percy, shoemaker
- 625McKeating Patk
- 645Vacant store, business and one more
- 651vacant
- 653Hays Lee and one more
- 655Misener Wm D, confectioner
- 659vacant and one more
- 665Corey Wm and one more
- 671Pirie Chas E
- 675Cagnacci P F and one more
- 679vacant
South side
- 622Murphy Matthew
- 626Pinchon Robt, barber
- 628vacant
- 632Rankin Alex, stationery
- 634Banks Benj, meats
- 636Lawson Arthur, grocer
- 638BLOCK and four more
- 640vacant
- 642vacant
- 644vacant
- 646Young James W
- 654B C Independent Undertakers
- 656vacant
- 664Deslaurier Isadore
- 676Burchell Edw
- 684McCall Robt
- 692vacant
- 694Edwards J & Co, grocers
- 698Cameron G H, drugs
Street section, p. 19
1920
32 doors listed, seven shops and businesses and two vacant.
North side
- 601Fugino B, confectioner and one more
- 603Cathie Alex
- 623Nicholson A E
- 625McKeating Patk
- 641Broadway Gasoline Sta
- 645Martin Mrs Edith
- 651Winbow Mrs —
- 653Anderson Mrs W J and one more
- 659Emslie Jemima
- 665Gant Herbt and one more
- 671Duncan Andw
- 675Duffy D and one more
- 679McArdle Maurice
South side
- 622Hale David B
- 626Pinchon Robt, barber
- 628vacant
- 632Carter Harry W
- 634Harrington Wm, meats
- 636Weaver & Wiberg
- 638Block and four more
- 640Macartney Saml
- 642Stockley Thos
- 644Smith Mrs L
- 646Carlson Thos
- 654Independent Undertakers and one more
- 656vacant
- 664Deslaurier Isadore
- 676Burchell Edw
- 684Buck James
- 692Cusick A E, confectioner
- 694Edwards J & Co
- 698Midway Pharmacy
Street section, p. 16
1925
36 doors listed, one shop or business, two vacant and one printed with a group label instead of names.
North side
- 601Nishikawa S
- 603Cooper M
- 623vacant
- 625Campsall F
- 645Martin E
- 651vacant
- 653Richmond J E and one more
- 655Harris W J
- 659Butler N
- 665Hays L and one more
- 671McPhail K
- 675McLean W and one more
- 679Keil R M
- 691Carle M A
- 695Emslie J
- 697Cottrell M A
South side
- 622Hale D
- 626Pinchon R W
- 628Coade & Daubney and one more
- 632Carter H W
- 634Williams A
- 636Wiberg C
- 638“Apartments” and four more
- 640Shrimpton Mrs E
- 642Shannon J
- 644Connor G
- 646Cameron Mrs A
- 654Edwards C F and one more
- 664Archambault P
- 676Burchell Mrs E
- 684Fowler A M
- 686Hays L
- 688Dowal C
- 692Poston C H
- 694Whidden A S
- 698Caldwell W H
Street section, p. 12
1930
38 doors listed, twelve shops and businesses, three vacant and one printed with a group label instead of names.
North side
- 601Nishikawa S
- 603vacant
- 625Campsall F
- 645Martin J A
- 653Pike F R and one more
- 655Red & White Store
- 659Butler N
- 665Hays L and one more
- 671Tomkins E
- 675vacant and one more
- 679Miller Mrs T
- 685Service Gar
- 691Brown Bros & Co Ltd
- 695Stewart G
- 697Bway Conf
South side
- 622Hale D B
- 626Green J W
- 628Vacant Store
- 632Bway Cycle Shop
- 634Hays L
- 636Tilikum Shoe Repairs
- 638“Apartments” and four more
- 640Shrimpton A
- 642Babbs Mrs A
- 644vacant
- 646Wolfe Miss E
- 652Wyatt T B
- 654Connaught Clnrs
- 656Durban Fish & Chips
- 658vacant
- 664Stringer Mrs E
- 676Burchill E
- 684Blanchard W
- 686Robertshaw A
- 688McGregor Mrs J C
- 692Western Mkt
- 694Red Elephant Gro
- 698Midway Pharm
Street section, p. 19
1935
37 doors listed, 16 shops and businesses and five vacant.
North side
- 601Nishiawa Mrs S, confectioner and one more
- 605Ideal Household Products, manufacturing chemists
- 625Campsall F
- 645*Martin J A
- 653Fitzpatrick E W and one more
- 655Harris W J, grocer
- 659Connaught Clnrs & Dyers
- 665Hays L
- 671Webber F J E
- 675Benjamin H and one more
- 679Edwards R W
- 685Service Gar and one more
- 691Bway Florists and one more
- 695Woodbridge Mrs E, dry goods and one more
- 697Bway Conf
South side
- 626Neilson C (wkshp)
- 628Uptown Plmbr
- 632Bway Cycle Shop and one more
- 634vacant
- 636vacant
- 638Browne J and three more
- 640Shrimpton A
- 642vacant
- 644Mossop Mrs H M
- 646Wolfe Miss E
- 652vacant
- 654Wearwell Shoe Reprs
- 656vacant
- 658Home Furnishing Co and one more
- 664Dunn C
- 676Paterson J M
- 684Arnott T A
- 686Mack's Used Magazine Exch and one more
- 688Margaret Anne Cake Shop
- 692Western Mkt, fruit and produce
- 694Red Elephant Conf and one more
- 698Midway Pharm
Street section, p. 16
1940
36 doors listed, 15 shops and businesses and four vacant.
North side
- 601Nishikawa Mrs S, confectioner and one more
- 605vacant
- 625*300 Transf and one more
- 635Cambie Thea
- 645*Martin J A
- 653Poulter Mrs E and one more
- 655Harris W J, grocer
- 659vacant
- 665Hays R L and one more
- 671Yanovich M
- 675Webber F and one more
- 679Blackman J A
- 685Service Gar
- 691Bway Florists and one more
- 695Beauty Box and one more
- 697Bway Conf and one more
South side
- 632vacant
- 634Cambie Conf and one more
- 636Ferguson & Hart, wholesale tobacco and confectioner
- 638Browne J and three more
- 640Robinson D
- 642Shrimpton A
- 644Mossop Mrs H M
- 646Wolfe Miss E
- 652Parsons Mrs E fish &, chips
- 654vacant
- 656Kosher Meat Mkt
- 658Cutler S K
- 664Dunn C
- 676Paterson J M
- 684Ballerone C E
- 686Wearwell Shoe Reprs
- 688Margaret Anne Cake Shop
- 692Western Mkt, produce
- 694Red Elephant Conf and one more
- 698Midway Pharm
Street section, p. 17
1945
34 doors listed and 13 shops and businesses.
North side
- 601Calbert Mrs B J
- 605Duffy C A, popcorn peddler
- 625*300 Transf and one more
- 635Cambie Thea
- 645*Martin J A
- 653Hanbury E J and two more
- 655Harris W J, grocer
- 659Kosher Co-op Meat Soc
- 665Lawrence W E
- 671Sharpe H R
- 675Gardner J R and one more
- 679Blackman J A
- 685Service Gar
- 691Bway Florists and one more
- 695Beauty Box and one more
- 697Paul's Conf
South side
- 632Cumming Mrs L
- 634*Ferguson & Hart, wholesale tobacco and confectioner
- 638Browne J and three more
- 640Robinson D
- 642Shrimpton A
- 644Messop Mrs H M
- 646Wolfe Miss E
- 652Brown R H, electrician contractor
- 656Pac Uphol
- 658Cutler S K
- 664*Duguid G
- 676Paterson J M
- 684Fisk C W
- 686Sally's Sewing Shop
- 688Wearwell Shoe Reprs
- 692Western Mkt, produce
- 694Star Conf & Gro and one more
- 698Midway Pharm
- 1of 5
- 2of 14
- 4of 17
- 5of 23
- 8of 21
- 7of 16
- 10of 19
- 13of 20
Epilogue
The house today
The address is still in use, but the City's record dates the building to 1973: the house in these directories is gone.
Since 1945
- 1973Today's building goes up, by the City's record.
- 1997 onLicensed as a parking lot (licences on record start in 1997).
- 2012–2024Licensed as a community association.
- 2025A building permit for alterations, valued at $500,000 (BP-2025-01887).
- 2025A building permit for alterations, valued at $300,000 (BP-2025-01763).
- 2026A building permit for alterations, valued at $289,000 (BP-2026-02971).
From City of Vancouver open data (Open Government Licence – Vancouver): the property tax report (BC Assessment's years, approximate for old buildings), business licences from 1997 (the kind of business only), issued building permits from 2017 and the heritage register.
The directories in this book stop in 1945. What they printed at 686 West Broadway is in the chapters before this one, every line with its page, so anyone can check it.
Sources
The page behind every line
Every year here comes from that year's printed city directory, held by the Vancouver Public Library. Canvassers compiled each one door to door, so a listing is who they recorded at the door, not a legal record of who owned or rented the house. Names are copied as printed, spellings and all. The street section lists each address in order; the name section lists each person with their work and address, which is where the jobs come from. h marks a householder, r someone living there, wid a widow. *: some member of the family owns the property, to the best of the directory's knowledge (its own mark, printed from 1935).
Anything we infer (a likely build date, a misprinted number, a renumbered address) is marked as inferred. Names are shown up to 1945; later years say only how the address was used. We link the library's page images and never reprint them.
Pages cited
- 1905Henderson's City of Vancouver Directory: street section p. 80
- 1910Henderson's City of Vancouver and North Vancouver Directory Part 1: street section p. 26
- 1915Henderson's Greater Vancouver City Directory: street section p. 19
- 1920Henderson's Vancouver Directory: street section p. 16
- 1925Wrigley-Henderson Amalgamated British Columbia Directory: street section p. 12
- 1930Wrigley's British Columbia Directory: street section p. 19
- 1935British Columbia and Yukon Directory: street section p. 16
- 1940British Columbia and Yukon Directory: street section p. 17
- 1945British Columbia and Yukon Directory: street section p. 15, p. 16
The 1912 map: Goad's Fire Insurance Map, georectified by the City of Vancouver. Today's buildings, the heritage register and the years since 1955: City of Vancouver open data. Both under the Open Government Licence – Vancouver.
Something wrong, or a name you'd like removed? Tell us.
Compiled by AddressLore, Vancouver, November 2026. Set in Libre Caslon.
A house biography
Vancouver, from the city directories
Another address?
Every house has its book
Find yours by its address: