A house biography
4656 West 3rd Avenue
West Point Grey, Vancouver
1920–1945
4656 West 3rd Avenue
Who lived there from 1920 to 1945, read line by line from Vancouver's city directories, with the page behind every line
Contents
- The house
- Before the first listing1905 to 1920
- Also at this address1920
- IThe Buchanans1925–1945
- Also at this address1930
- Also at this address1940
- The 4600 block, decade by decade1905–1945
- The house today
- Sources, page by page
AddressLore, Vancouver, 2026
Prologue
The house
Every directory that names anyone here, 1925 to 1945, names the Buchanan household, starting with J U Buchanan; the directory marks it * in 1935, 1940 and 1945 (some member of the family owns the property, to the best of the directory's knowledge). The 1920 name section gives John U Buchanan at this address (page 78), matched to the 1925 listing here by first name or initials (inferred). In 1930 the name section also gives John U Buchanan, a bookkeeper, here (page 91), tied to the 1925, 1930 and 1935 listings by first name or initials (inferred). And the 1940 name section has John U Buchanan, retired, at this address as well (page 77), matched by first name or initials to the 1935 and 1940 listings here (inferred).
Before the first listing
1905 to 1920: the address is not listed in the directories.
1920
Also at this address
from the name section
The 1920 name section gives this address for Ada L Balfour, widow of James Balfour, under a surname no household here was listed under. The directory doesn't say whether this person boarded, rented a room or was family.
1920
Name section, as printed
Balfour Ada L wid James r 4656 West 3rd Avenue
Chapter I
The Buchanans
the household, 1925 to 1945
The 1925 directory is the first we read to list the number, with J U Buchanan, and the Buchanan name stays through 1945, five directories in all (printed “Buchanan J U” and “Buchanan Mrs A E”), the name marked * in 1935, 1940 and 1945 (some member of the family owns the property, to the best of the directory's knowledge).
1920
The name section gives John U Buchanan as the householder, with no work.
Name section, as printed
Buchanan John U h 4656 West 3rd Avenue
1925
From 1925, J U Buchanan lived at 4656 West 3rd Avenue.
Street section, as printed
- Buchanan J U
1930
John U Buchanan, a bookkeeper, shared 4656 West 3rd Avenue in 1930 with two people under other surnames.
Street section, as printed
- Buchanan J U
Name section, as printed
Buchanan John U bkpr h 4656 West 3rd Avenue
1935
J U Buchanan is listed at 4656 West 3rd Avenue in 1935; as far as the directory knew, a member of the family owned it.
Street section, as printed
- *Buchanan J U
1940
John U Buchanan, retired, shared 4656 West 3rd Avenue in 1940 with one person under another surname.
Street section, as printed
- *Buchanan J U
Name section, as printed
Buchanan John U retired h 4656 West 3rd Avenue
1945
Street section, as printed
- *Buchanan Mrs A E
1930
Also at this address
from the name section
In 1930 the name section lists A E Hensley, an assistant at UBC, and Charles A E Hensley, a student at UBC at this address, under other surnames.
1930
Name section, as printed
Hensley A E asst UBC r 4656 West 3rd Avenue
Hensley Chas A E studt UBC r 4656 West 3rd Avenue
1940
Also at this address
from the name section
Barbara H Balfour is listed here in 1940 as well, under a surname of its own.
1940
Name section, as printed
Balfour Barbara H r 4656 West 3rd Avenue
The street
The 4600 block, decade by decade
West 3rd Avenue, West Point Grey, every door the directories list
The 1905, 1910 and 1915 directories list no one on this block.
1920
Four doors listed and one vacant.
South side
- 4620Watson Robt
- 4626vacant
- 4646Fee Wilfred J
- 4678Hilchey Chas A
Street section, p. 163
1925
Nine doors listed and one vacant.
North side
- 4623Gray J S
- 4633Bannerman A K
- 4679Munroe Mrs M
South side
- 4616Watson R D
- 4636occupied, no name given
- 4646Mackenzie D C
- 4656Buchanan J U
- 4678vacant
- 4696Unsworth C
Street section, p. 142
1930
13 doors listed.
North side
- 4633Bannerman A K
- 4645Kennedy J A
- 4679Muckle B J
South side
- 4606Wilson S
- 4616Watson R D
- 4626Gray J S
- 4636Frattinger A F
- 4646MacKenzie Dr D C
- 4656Buchanan J U
- 4666Moore W J
- 4678Hilchey C A
- 4686Lawrence R
- 4696Unsworth A W C
Street section, p. 189
1935
17 doors listed.
North side
- 4627*Fouks M
- 4633*Bannerman A K
- 4645*Gates H F
- 4655*Macdonald A P G
- 4679MacCrostie J R
- 4697*Hanna R S
South side
- 4606*Wilson W A
- 4616*Watson Mrs N M
- 4618French Miss J
- 4626*Gray J S
- 4636*Frattinger A F
- 4646*MacKenzie Dr D C
- 4656*Buchanan J U
- 4666*Moore W J
- 4678*Stacey L B
- 4686Lougheed D H
- 4696*Unsworth A W C
Street section, p. 168
1940
18 doors listed.
North side
- 4627*McGregor A, telephone and power contractor
- 4633*Bannerman A K
- 4645*Gates H F
- 4655*Macdonald A P G
- 4665*Downs J F
- 4679*MacCrostie J R
- 4697*Grozelle J J
South side
- 4606*Wilson W A
- 4616Hooper C F T
- 4618*Watson Mrs N M
- 4626*Gray J S
- 4636*Frattinger A F
- 4646*MacKenzie Dr D C
- 4656*Buchanan J U
- 4666*Moore W J
- 4678Black J E
- 4686*Hutchinson T H
- 4696*Unsworth A W C
Street section, p. 180
1945
18 doors listed.
North side
- 4627*McGregor Mrs E
- 4633*Bannerman A K
- 4645*Charles C W
- 4655*Macdonald A P G
- 4665*Downs J F
- 4679*MacCrostie J R
- 4697*Rekdal K J
South side
- 4606*Graham A G
- 4616*Cuthbert G L
- 4618Williams H W H
- 4626*Allen Mrs E C
- 4636*Frattinger A F
- 4646*Stevens H T
- 4656*Buchanan Mrs A E
- 4666*Semmens F H
- 4678Stone W G
- 4686*Hutchinson T H
- 4696*Robbins W
Street section, p. 168
- 0of 1
- 5of 6
- 9of 13
- 11of 17
- 8of 18
Epilogue
The house today
The address is still in use, but the City's record dates the building to 1991: the house in these directories is gone.
Since 1945
- 1991Today's building goes up, by the City's record.
From City of Vancouver open data (Open Government Licence – Vancouver): the property tax report (BC Assessment's years, approximate for old buildings), business licences from 1997 (the kind of business only), issued building permits from 2017 and the heritage register.
The directories in this book stop in 1945. What they printed at 4656 West 3rd Avenue is in the chapters before this one, every line with its page, so anyone can check it.
Sources
The page behind every line
Every year here comes from that year's printed city directory, held by the Vancouver Public Library. Canvassers compiled each one door to door, so a listing is who they recorded at the door, not a legal record of who owned or rented the house. Names are copied as printed, spellings and all. The street section lists each address in order; the name section lists each person with their work and address, which is where the jobs come from. h marks a householder, r someone living there, wid a widow. *: some member of the family owns the property, to the best of the directory's knowledge (its own mark, printed from 1935).
Anything we infer (a likely build date, a misprinted number, a renumbered address) is marked as inferred. Names are shown up to 1945; later years say only how the address was used. We link the library's page images and never reprint them.
Pages cited
- 1920Henderson's Vancouver Directory: street section p. 163; name section p. 27, p. 78
- 1925Wrigley-Henderson Amalgamated British Columbia Directory: street section p. 142
- 1930Wrigley's British Columbia Directory: street section p. 189; name section p. 91, p. 312
- 1935British Columbia and Yukon Directory: street section p. 168
- 1940British Columbia and Yukon Directory: street section p. 180; name section p. 28, p. 77
- 1945British Columbia and Yukon Directory: street section p. 168
The 1912 map: Goad's Fire Insurance Map, georectified by the City of Vancouver. Today's buildings, the heritage register and the years since 1955: City of Vancouver open data. Both under the Open Government Licence – Vancouver.
Something wrong, or a name you'd like removed? Tell us.
Compiled by AddressLore, Vancouver, November 2026. Set in Libre Caslon.
A house biography
Vancouver, from the city directories
Another address?
Every house has its book
Find yours by its address: