A house biography
457 East Georgia Street
Strathcona, Vancouver
1905–1945
457 East Georgia Street
Who lived there from 1905 to 1945, read line by line from Vancouver's city directories, with the page behind every line
Contents
- The house
- IThe Browns1905
- IIThe Seedses1906
- IIIThe Currys1907–1912
- The 1911 census1911
- Between families1913
- IVThe Sucattos1915
- VThe Gars1920
- The 1921 census1921
- VI“Chinese”1925
- VII“Orientals”1930–1935
- The 1931 census1931
- VIIIThe Gars1940
- IX“Orientals”1945
- The 400 block, decade by decade1905–1945
- The house today
- Sources, page by page
AddressLore, Vancouver, 2026
Prologue
The house
For six directories, 1907 to 1912, the Curry name is listed here, starting with Robert Curry, a bartender. Only four other addresses on the block kept a name as long. Instead of names, the directories print “Chinese” here in 1925, and “Orientals” in 1930, 1935 and 1945. The 1940 name section gives Ying Gar at this address (page 215), matched to the 1940 listing here by first name or initials (inferred).
Where the directory printed “Chinese” or “Orientals”, its canvassers wrote a group label in place of the residents' names; we show what was printed, and the names it never recorded we can't give.
Chapter I
The Browns
the household, 1905
William E Brown, an engineer, is listed at 457 East Georgia Street in 1905.
1905
Street section, as printed
- Brown, Wm. E.engineer
Chapter II
The Seedses
the household, 1906
J T Seeds, a teamster, is listed at 457 East Georgia Street in 1906.
1906
Street section, as printed
- Seeds, J. T.teamster
Chapter III
The Currys
the household, 1907 to 1912
Robert Curry, a bartender, is listed at 457 East Georgia Street in 1907.
1907
Street section, as printed
- Curry, Robt.bartender
1908
Street section, as printed
- Curry Robertbartender
1909
In 1909 Robert Curry is still at 457 East Georgia Street, as in 1908.
Street section, as printed
- Curry Robertbarkndr
1910
Street section, as printed
- Curry Robertbartndr
1911
Street section, as printed
- Curry Robert
1912
Street section, as printed
- Curry Robt
June 1, 1911
The 1911 census
Library and Archives Canada, the population schedule
On June 1, 1911, the census found two households here, 17 people in all: the first, four people, and the second, 13 people (inferred: the census gives the street the name it had then).
Origin, as the census gave it: 13 Italian, three English and one not given or not readable. Where they were born: 13 in Italy, two in British Columbia and two in Prince Edward Island.
Origins are the census's own words, some no longer used. The census names everyone in each household. We name a person only with their record at Library and Archives Canada, and we don't hold those records for 1911, so we give the counts. Library and Archives Canada, Census of Canada, 1911 (RG31, Statistics Canada fonds), Vancouver, North Vancouver and South Vancouver (district 12), sub-district 26 (record 6585309), pages 27 and 28.
Between families
1913: the address is vacant in the directory.
Chapter IV
The Sucattos
the household, 1915
S Sucatto lived at 457 East Georgia Street in 1915.
1915
Street section, as printed
- Sucatto S
Chapter V
The Gars
the household, 1920
By 1920 Ying Gar lived at 457 East Georgia Street. The 1920 name section doesn't list this household.
1920
Street section, as printed
- Gar Ying
June 1, 1921
The 1921 census
Library and Archives Canada, the population schedule
On June 1, 1921, ten years on, the census found one household here: nine people, renting at $30 a month, in five rooms. The census lists it as a single house, built of wood.
Origins in 1921: nine Chinese. Their birthplaces: nine in China.
The census names them:
- Law, Sam, record at Library and Archives Canadahead, 50
- Law, Wah, record at Library and Archives Canadalodger, 30
- Law, Mrs Sam, record at Library and Archives Canadalodger, 35
- Law, Mar, record at Library and Archives Canadalodger, 36
- Law, Foo, record at Library and Archives Canadalodger, 40
- Law, Gerg, record at Library and Archives Canadalodger, 44
- Law, Char Ho, record at Library and Archives Canadalodger, 42
- Law, Lucy Heny, record at Library and Archives Canadalodger, 39
- Law, Kary, record at Library and Archives Canadalodger, 30
Names and relationships are as Library and Archives Canada's index of the census gives them; each links to its record there. Library and Archives Canada, Census of Canada, 1921 (RG31, Statistics Canada fonds), Vancouver Centre (district 22), sub-district 63, page 24, line 46.
Chapter VI
“Chinese”
as the directory printed it, in place of names
The Gar name lasts one directory, like the name before it; in 1925 the directory prints “Chinese” here instead. The people who lived here then are not named in any section of the directory, so this chapter can't name them either.
1925
Street section, as printed
- “Chinese”
Chapter VII
“Orientals”
as the directory printed it, in place of names
In 1930 and 1935 it prints “Orientals”. As in Chapter VI, no section of the directory names the people behind the label. The 1931 census counted the people behind the label: the 1931 counts follow this chapter.
1930
Street section, as printed
- “Orientals”
1935
Street section, as printed
- “Orientals”
June 1, 1931
The 1931 census
Library and Archives Canada, the population schedule
The directory printed “Orientals” here in 1930 and 1935, in place of names. The census, taken door to door, counted the household that year.
On June 1, 1931, ten years after that, the census found one household here: five people, renting at $25 a month, in seven rooms. The census again lists it as a single house, built of wood.
By 1931, the origins given: five Chinese. And the birthplaces: five in China.
Library and Archives Canada, Census of Canada, 1931 (RG31, Statistics Canada fonds), Vancouver Centre (electoral district 236), sub-district 55 (record 85933030), page 23, line 26.
Chapter VIII
The Gars
the household, 1940
Ying Gar is the householder at 457 East Georgia Street in 1940; the directory prints no work beside the name.
1940
Street section, as printed
- Gar Ying
Name section, as printed
Gar Ying h 457 East Georgia
Chapter IX
“Orientals”
as the directory printed it, in place of names
In 1945, the last directory whose names we show, the Gar name gives way to “Orientals”, printed in place of names.
1945
Street section, as printed
- “Orientals”
The street
The 400 block, decade by decade
East Georgia Street, Strathcona, every door the directories list
The Curry name moves along the block: at 463 in 1906, then here in 1907–1912 (the same family, or another with the same surname: inferred).
In 1935 this was one of eight doors on the block where the directory printed “Orientals” instead of names; here it printed “Orientals” in 1930 and 1935.
1905
14 doors listed, one shop or business and one vacant.
North side
- 401vacant
- 407Clement Bros., butcher shop
- 411Carlson, H. W., captain
- 415Macleod, John W. S., accountant
- 421Edgett, Arthur, master mariner
- 429Smith, James I., teamster
- 433McGillivray, William, logger
- 439Harris, H., fisherman
- 441Harris, Edward George, brakeman
- 447Richardson, Charles, conductor
- 451Anderson, Geo. H., clerk
- 457Brown, Wm. E., engineer
- 463Dunning, Asa, scaler
- 467Coombs, James, fisherman
Street section, p. 53
1906
14 doors listed, one shop or business and two vacant.
North side
- 401vacant
- 407Clement Bros., butcher shop and one more
- 411Carlson, H. W., captain
- 415Macleod, John W. S., accountant
- 421Edgett, Arthur, master mariner
- 429Smith, James I., teamster
- 433McGillivray, Cyrus William, logger
- 439Harris, H., fisherman
- 441Harris, Edward George, brakeman
- 447Richardson, Charles, conductor
- 451Tuttle, Charles A
- 457Seeds, J. T., teamster
- 463Curry, Robert, bartender
- 467vacant
Street section, p. 73
1907
15 doors listed and two shops and businesses.
North side
- 401Union Dye Works, Harrington Bros., managers
- 407Chambers & Harrison
- 411Carlson, H. W., captain
- 415Macleod, John W. S., accountant
- 421Edgett, Arthur, master mariner
- 429Smith, James I., teamster
- 433Pendygrasse, Harold L
- 439Smitton, Arthur E., Salvation Army
- 441Harris, Edward George, brakeman
- 447Richardson, Charles, conductor
- 451Cosgrave, Fred., C. P. R. clerk
- 457Curry, Robt., bartender
- 463King, George, real estate
- 467Elliott, Geo. A., paperhanger
South side
- 446Lothian, Duncan S., foreman
1908
14 doors listed, one shop or business and one printed with a group label instead of names.
North side
- 401Union Dye Works Harrington Bros managers
- 407Lapare Jules, grocers
- 411Carlson H W, captain
- 415Macleod John W S, accountant
- 421Edgett Frank A, accountant
- 429Smith James J, teamster
- 433Pendygrasse Harold L
- 439Morris Frank, major Salvation Army and one more
- 441Harris Edward George, brakeman
- 447Richardson Charles, conductor
- 451“Italians”
- 457Curry Robert, bartender
- 463King George, real estate
- 467Elliott Victor, paperhanger
Street section, p. 262
1909
14 doors listed, three shops and businesses and one vacant.
North side
- 401Hall Harry B, real estate
- 407Lapore Jules, grocer
- 411Lundborg Oscar L, manager
- 415Greening James, mariner
- 421Edgett Frank A, grocer
- 429Smith James J, teamster
- 433Westwood George W, assayer
- 439vacant
- 441Harris Edward G, brakeman
- 447Richardson Charles, conductor
- 451Lundi Peter, shoemaker
- 457Curry Robert
- 463King George, real estate
- 467Elliott George A, paperhanger
Street section, p. 327
1910
14 doors listed and four shops and businesses.
North side
- 401Union Dye Wks and one more
- 407Akevro Joseph, grocer
- 411Irwin Robert S, traveller
- 415Greening James, mariner
- 421Edgett Frank A, grocer
- 429Smith James J, teamster
- 433Westwood George W, assayer
- 439MacDougall John, real estate
- 441Harris Edward G, brakeman
- 447Richardson Charles, conductor
- 451Lundi Peter, shoemaker
- 457Curry Robert, bartender
- 463King George, real estate
- 467Grady Patrick, fisherman
Street section, p. 98
1911
13 doors listed.
North side
- 407Akevro Joseph
- 411Karlier Frank J and one more
- 415Greening James
- 421Edgett Rachael, widow Frank
- 429Smith James J
- 433Westward George W
- 439MacDougall John
- 441Harris Edward G
- 447Richardson Charles
- 451Lundi Peter
- 457Curry Robert
- 463Ayres Charles D
- 467Grady Patrick
Street section, p. 323
1912
14 doors listed, one shop or business and one vacant.
North side
- 401Hopps & Duker, signs
- 407Harrington A N, dyer
- 411Black Mrs D and one more
- 415Greening James
- 421Edgett Mrs Rachael
- 429Smith James J
- 433vacant
- 439Dutailly Jennie
- 441Harris Edw G
- 447Richardson Chas
- 451Alvaro Joe, grocer
- 457Curry Robt
- 463Annesley Everett
- 467Hill J F
Street section, p. 63
1915
15 doors listed, two shops and businesses, one vacant and one printed with a group label instead of names.
North side
- 401Main Junk Co
- 407Harrington A N, dyer
- 411Weber Lewis
- 415Gentile John
- 421Edgett Mrs Rachael
- 429Atkinson Wm
- 431Parkview Rooms
- 433vacant
- 439Lacterman Joseph
- 441Jeffery Bridger
- 447Llewellyn David H
- 451Hart Mrs Sarah, grocer
- 457Sucatto S
- 463“Chinese”
- 467Boige Anna
Street section, p. 71
1920
15 doors listed and three vacant.
North side
- 401vacant
- 407vacant
- 411Jonkin Joseph
- 415Gordon Morris
- 421vacant
- 429Braga Chas
- 431Burleith House
- 433Lipovsky Mrs Sara
- 439Jung Chong
- 441Lee Sing
- 447Harris Wm H
- 453Wong Kong Kem, grocer
- 457Gar Ying
- 463Suey Sun Tong
- 467Leclerque Chas
Street section, p. 49
1925
14 doors listed, two shops and businesses, one vacant and two printed with a group label instead of names.
North side
- 401Wah Shurng Wing Co
- 411Fong Lun Tong Society
- 415Boury P
- 421Alvaro J
- 429Holden Mrs O
- 431Burleith Hse
- 433Farkay Noodle Fact
- 439“Chinese”
- 441vacant
- 447Spatari F
- 453Furnkawa S
- 457“Chinese”
- 463Miller A
- 467Angelo P
Street section, p. 42
1930
14 doors listed, two shops and businesses and seven printed with a group label instead of names.
North side
- 401Avenue Super Service
- 411“Orientals”
- 415“Orientals”
- 421Alvaro J
- 429“Orientals”
- 431Burleith Hse
- 433Far Kay Noodle Fcty Co
- 439“Orientals”
- 441“Orientals”
- 447Spatari F
- 453Sing Lim and one more
- 457“Orientals”
- 463“Orientals”
- 467Weinstein I
Street section, p. 60
1935
15 doors listed, three shops and businesses and eight printed with a group label instead of names.
North side
- 401Avenue Service
- 411“Orientals”
- 415“Orientals”
- 421*Alvaro J, coal & wood
- 429“Orientals”
- 431Burleith House
- 433Far Kay Noodle Fcty
- 439“Orientals”
- 441“Orientals”
- 447Spatari F
- 451“Orientals”
- 453Kitagawa H, barber and one more
- 457“Orientals”
- 463“Orientals”
- 467*Viennet M, taxi
Street section, p. 54
1940
13 doors listed, two shops and businesses and one printed with a group label instead of names.
North side
- 401Paramount Serv and one more
- 411*Fong Lun Tong and one more
- 415*On Wah Fong
- 421Miran M
- 429Bandura M
- 431Burleith House, rooms to let
- 433Far Kay Noodle Fcty
- 439*Wong Wah
- 441*Quen Wing
- 447Spatari F
- 457Gar Ying
- 463Fong J
- 467*Viennet Mrs J
Street section, p. 55
1945
13 doors listed, three shops and businesses and six printed with a group label instead of names.
North side
- 401Paramount Serv, garage
- 411Fong Lun Tong
- 415“Orientals”
- 421“Orientals”
- 429“Orientals”
- 431Burleith Rooms
- 433Farkay Noodle Fcty
- 439Wong Wah
- 441“Orientals”
- 447Nellsen J
- 457“Orientals”
- 463“Orientals”
- 467*Viennet Mrs J
Street section, p. 52
- 8of 11
- 6of 11
- 10of 11
- 8of 11
- 10of 13
- 11of 13
- 6of 12
- 2of 11
- 0of 8
- 0of 6
- 3of 5
- 2of 4
- 2of 3
- 3of 4
Epilogue
The house today
457 East Georgia Street isn't on the City's list of addresses today, so the building is probably gone (inferred).
Since 1945
- 1961The City's Redevelopment Project 1 (area A-1.3) puts the north side of the 400 block of East Georgia Street inside a clearance area, and the City's later maps show the old lots gone. (inferred) Its status map marks 12 buildings on this side of the block as demolished. (LEG1350.02, undated, about 1961)
- 1968The City's existing land-use map shows the block as “multiple”. (LEG37.28, dated Aug. 1968)
The urban-renewal plans: City of Vancouver Archives, each record linked on its line; the plans and maps are under the City's copyright, so we tell what they show and don't reproduce them.
The directories in this book stop in 1945. What they printed at 457 East Georgia Street is in the chapters before this one, every line with its page, so anyone can check it.
Sources
The page behind every line
Every year here comes from that year's printed city directory, held by the Vancouver Public Library. Canvassers compiled each one door to door, so a listing is who they recorded at the door, not a legal record of who owned or rented the house. Names are copied as printed, spellings and all. The street section lists each address in order; the name section lists each person with their work and address, which is where the jobs come from. h marks a householder, r someone living there, wid a widow. *: some member of the family owns the property, to the best of the directory's knowledge (its own mark, printed from 1935).
Anything we infer (a likely build date, a misprinted number, a renumbered address) is marked as inferred. Names are shown up to 1945; later years say only how the address was used. We link the library's page images and never reprint them.
Pages cited
- 1905Henderson's City of Vancouver Directory: street section p. 53
- 1906Henderson's City of Vancouver Directory: street section p. 73
- 1907Henderson's City of Vancouver Directory: street section p. 185, p. 186
- 1908Henderson's City of Vancouver Directory: street section p. 262
- 1909Henderson's City of Vancouver Directory: street section p. 327
- 1910Henderson's City of Vancouver and North Vancouver Directory Part 1: street section p. 98
- 1911Henderson's Greater Vancouver New Westminster and Fraser Valley Directory: street section p. 323
- 1912Henderson's Greater Vancouver Directory Part 1: street section p. 63
- 1913Henderson's Greater Vancouver City Directory Part 1: street section p. 82
- 1915Henderson's Greater Vancouver City Directory: street section p. 71
- 1920Henderson's Vancouver Directory: street section p. 49
- 1925Wrigley-Henderson Amalgamated British Columbia Directory: street section p. 42
- 1930Wrigley's British Columbia Directory: street section p. 60
- 1935British Columbia and Yukon Directory: street section p. 54
- 1940British Columbia and Yukon Directory: street section p. 55; name section p. 215
- 1945British Columbia and Yukon Directory: street section p. 52
The 1912 map: Goad's Fire Insurance Map, georectified by the City of Vancouver. Today's buildings, the heritage register and the years since 1955: City of Vancouver open data. Both under the Open Government Licence – Vancouver. The 1911 census: Library and Archives Canada, Census of Canada, 1911, population schedule, read by us for addresses and counts; a household tied to this address by inference is marked inferred. The 1921 census: Library and Archives Canada, Census of Canada, 1921, population schedule, read by us for addresses and counts, with names from Library and Archives Canada's index of it. The 1931 census: Library and Archives Canada, Census of Canada, 1931, population schedule, read by us for addresses and counts.
Something wrong, or a name you'd like removed? Tell us.
Compiled by AddressLore, Vancouver, November 2026. Set in Libre Caslon.
A house biography
Vancouver, from the city directories
Another address?
Every house has its book
Find yours by its address: